Sons of Liberty Museum: website header
Sons of Liberty Museum: mobile website header

Notice: Ads help support our website operation, if you would like to turn them OFF for this visit;


The U.S. Army's Antisubmarine Campaign (7 December 1941 - 2 September 1945): America's Forgotten Battle for the Atlantic

Introduction

Following the Pearl Harbor attack, the United States Army Air Forces (AAF) took on the critical task of aerial antisubmarine warfare, conducting extensive patrols over U.S. coastal waters, the Caribbean, Gulf of Mexico, Atlantic Ocean, and the Panama Canal approaches. This largely forgotten campaign represents one of the most significant contributions of the U.S. Army to winning the Battle of the Atlantic during World War II.

The Genesis of America's Submarine Crisis: Operation Drumbeat and the Second Happy Time

The German U-Boat Offensive Begins

The Second Happy Time, officially known as Operation Paukenschlag (Operation Drumbeat), launched on January 12, 1942, when Admiral Karl Dönitz deployed German U-boats to attack merchant shipping along the American East Coast. By January 1942, the U-boat Force had grown from 57 to 248 submarines and had already sunk 1,124 Allied ships totaling 5.27 million gross registered tons.

Key Statistics of the U-Boat Threat:

  • Total U-boats commissioned: 830
  • U-boats sunk during the war: 717
  • German submariners who did not return: 27,490 of 40,000
  • Ships sunk by U-boats worldwide: 2,919 vessels (14.59 million gross tons)

America's Vulnerable Coastline

When Hitler declared war on the United States in December 1941, American coastal defenses were poorly prepared for submarine warfare, with vintage gunboats dating back to 1905, some 1919 patrol boats, four converted yachts, and seven Coast Guard cutters comprising the Eastern Sea Frontier defense.

"The crew of that plane had been as inexperienced at interpreting the results of attacks as they were at launching them." - Commentary on early U.S. Army Air Forces antisubmarine efforts

The Formation of the Army Air Forces Antisubmarine Command (AAFAC)

Command Structure and Leadership

The Army Air Forces Antisubmarine Command was formed on October 15, 1942, under the leadership of Brigadier General Westside T. Larson, establishing a single command to control all antisubmarine warfare activities of the Army Air Forces. The command was formed from the resources of I Bomber Command, which had been carrying out the antisubmarine mission in the Atlantic and Caribbean since the Attack on Pearl Harbor.

AAFAC Organizational Timeline:

  • October 13, 1942: AAFAC constituted
  • October 15, 1942: AAFAC activated under Brig. Gen. Westside T. Larson
  • August 31, 1943: Redesignated as I Bomber Command
  • March 21, 1946: Inactivated
  • October 8, 1948: Disbanded

Wing and Squadron Organization

By November 20, 1942, the AAFAC had organized its inherited squadrons into the 25th and 26th Antisubmarine Wings, with headquarters in New York and Miami respectively, controlling approximately 40 percent of AAFAC squadrons.

Major AAFAC Units:

  • 25th Antisubmarine Wing (New York)
  • 26th Antisubmarine Wing (Miami)
  • 1st Antisubmarine Wing (Provisional) (later 2037th)
  • 479th Antisubmarine Group (England)
  • 480th Antisubmarine Group (Morocco)

Aircraft and Technology: The B-24 Liberator Revolution

The Liberator's Antisubmarine Configuration

The VLR (Very Long Range) Liberators sacrificed armor and gun turrets to save weight while carrying extra aviation gasoline in bomb-bay tanks, and were equipped with ASV Mk. II radar which, together with the Leigh light, gave them the ability to hunt U-boats by day and night.

B-24 Antisubmarine Specifications:

  • Range: Up to 1,000 miles radius for patrol missions
  • Maximum Range: Nearly 1,600 miles on high-altitude missions
  • Radar Equipment: ASV Mk. II microwave radar
  • Armament: Depth charges, bombs, rockets, and machine guns
  • Special Equipment: Leigh lights for night operations

Force Expansion and Equipment

By January 1943, AAFAC consisted of 19 squadrons operating 209 planes, of which only 20 were B-24s. The command grew rapidly until September 1943, when there were 25 antisubmarine squadrons, most equipped with specially modified B-24s.

AAFAC Aircraft Inventory by September 1943:

  • 187 operational B-24 Liberators
  • 80 B-25 Mitchell medium bombers
  • 12 B-17 Flying Fortresses
  • 7 Lockheed B-34 Venturas
  • Total: 286 aircraft (104 equipped with radar)

Combat Operations and Battle Zones

Atlantic and Caribbean Operations

In the American Theater, USAAF aircraft flew over 135,000 operational combat hours on antisubmarine patrols and participated in 96 attacks on German submarines between December 7, 1941, and August 24, 1943.

Primary Operating Areas:

  • East Coast: Maine to Florida
  • Gulf of Mexico: Texas to Florida
  • Caribbean Sea: Trinidad to Cuba
  • Atlantic Ocean: Newfoundland to Brazil
  • Panama Canal Zone: Pacific and Atlantic approaches

European Theater Operations

In November 1942, two AAFAC squadrons flying radar-equipped B-24s moved to England, with six squadrons eventually serving in the eastern Atlantic areas, specifically the Bay of Biscay and Morocco.

European Bases:

  • RAF St Eval, Cornwall, England
  • RAF Dunkeswell, Devon, England
  • Craw Field, French Morocco
  • Operating units extending to Tunisia

Notable Commanders and Personnel

Brigadier General Westside T. Larson

Commanding General of AAFAC, Larson advocated for the command to be considered the "strategic" antisubmarine air force, deployed as a long-range, mobile striking force. He was photographed commending Captain Jack H. Shaw, navigator of B-24D "Tidewater Tillie," after successfully sinking a German U-boat in the Bay of Biscay.

Key Squadron Commanders

Major AAFAC Squadron Leaders:

  • 20th Antisubmarine Squadron: Operating from Newfoundland
  • 479th Antisubmarine Group: England operations
  • 480th Antisubmarine Group: Morocco operations
  • 25th Bombardment Group: Trinidad and Caribbean

Weapons and Tactics

Antisubmarine Weaponry

Primary Weapons Systems:

  • Depth Charges: Standard antisubmarine ordnance
  • Mk. 47 Torpedo: Air-dropped submarine torpedoes
  • Rockets: Forward-firing rocket projectiles
  • Machine Guns: .50-caliber defensive armament
  • Bombs: General purpose and specialized antisubmarine bombs

Tactical Development

Early in the war, the USAAF primarily used aerial patrol to restrict and hamper enemy operations, requiring precise navigation, reliable communications, and accurate identification of surface craft to avoid attacks on friendly vessels.

Combat Tactics:

  • Convoy Escort: Protection of merchant shipping
  • Offensive Sweeps: Proactive submarine hunting
  • Coordinated Attacks: Integration with Navy surface forces
  • Night Operations: Utilizing radar and Leigh lights

German U-Boat Forces and Notable Adversaries

U-Boat Types and Capabilities

Primary German Submarines:

  • Type IX Long-Range: Atlantic patrol boats
  • Type VII Medium-Range: Coastal operations
  • Type XXI: Advanced late-war submarines with snorkel technology

Notable German Commanders

Key U-Boat Aces:

  • Reinhard Hardegen (U-123): Operation Drumbeat leader
  • Johann Mohr (U-124): Sank four tankers in one night
  • Hans-Dieter Heinicke (U-576): Lost off North Carolina

German Weapons and Technology

U-Boat Armament:

  • Torpedoes: Primary weapon system
  • Deck Guns: Surface engagement capability
  • Anti-Aircraft Guns: Defense against air attack
  • Enigma Communications: Encrypted radio systems

Major Battles and Engagements

The Battle for the American Coast (January-August 1942)

During the first half of 1942, more than 360 merchant ships and tankers totaling about 2,250,000 gross tons went to the bottom in coastal waters from Canada to the Caribbean.

Significant Attacks:

  • SS Cyclops: First victim, January 12, 1942
  • Lady Hawkins: 251 casualties, January 19, 1942
  • Gulfamerica: Torpedoed off Jacksonville, Florida

The Gulf of Mexico Campaign

Of the twenty-three U-boats operating in the Gulf, only one was lost - the U-166, which remained a mystery for fifty-nine years until confirmed sunk by PC-566 on July 30, 1942.

The Atlantic Gap Operations

The extension of AAFAC operations beyond the western Atlantic was dictated by fundamental changes in German strategy, as U-boats concentrated forces in Atlantic convoy lanes by fall 1942.

The Inter-Service Rivalry and Command Transfer

Army-Navy Disputes

The AAFAC faced significant inter-service rivalry with the U.S. Navy concerning operational control, with the Navy treating Army units as temporary additions operating "in lieu of" Navy squadrons.

Transfer to Naval Control

On July 9, 1943, following a compromise by General Arnold and Admiral McCain, the AAF and Navy agreed that AAFAC would gradually withdraw from antisubmarine operations, transferring 77 B-24 Liberators to the Navy by October 6, 1943.

Impact and Legacy

Statistical Achievement

AAFAC Combat Record:

  • 135,000+ combat flying hours
  • 96 attacks on German submarines
  • Multiple U-boat kills confirmed
  • Significant disruption of German submarine operations

Strategic Significance

The U-boat threat was successfully contained by mid-1943, with the establishment of the convoy system and improved antisubmarine measures leading to dramatically reduced shipping losses.

Conclusion

The U.S. Army's Antisubmarine Campaign from December 7, 1941, to September 2, 1945, represents a crucial but often overlooked chapter in World War II history. Through the dedication of the Army Air Forces Antisubmarine Command and its personnel, America successfully defended its coastlines and shipping lanes against the German U-boat threat. The campaign demonstrated the importance of inter-service cooperation, technological innovation, and the decisive role of air power in naval warfare.

The legacy of this campaign continues to influence modern antisubmarine warfare doctrine and serves as a testament to the courage and skill of the airmen who flew long, dangerous patrols over the Atlantic to protect the lifelines that sustained the Allied war effort.

References

Sources and References

Primary Sources

Secondary Sources

Additional Reading